Highlights From the Crime Desk is Checkpoint's monthly roundup of criminal tax cases. This month's round up contains the usual mix of tax preparers preparing false returns and employers who don't pay their trust fund taxes, along with a few embezzlers and a financial professional promoting a charitable deduction tax fraud scheme and ERC fraud.
Employment tax credit fraud.
A New Jersey tax preparer was charged with fraudulently filing over 1,000 tax returns falsely claiming COVID-19-related employment tax credits. Those returns sought over $124,000,000 from the IRS. According to the government, Leon Haynes allegedly prepared and submitted approximately 1,387 false refund claims to the IRS for COVID-related tax credits. Haynes allegedly told his clients that the government was giving out COVID-relief money for businesses and that they were eligible for the money simply because they had a business. Haynes then submitted refund claims to the IRS on behalf of his own and his clients' businesses that grossly overstated the number of employees and amount of wages paid by the businesses. The IRS allegedly mailed Haynes multiple tax refund checks totaling $1,007,966 for his own companies and disbursed a total of $31.6 million in refunds to Haynes' clients based on the false refund claims that Haynes submitted. Haynes allegedly charged his clients fees up to 15% of the refund they received.
Employment taxes.
A Colorado businessman was sentenced to 15 months in prison for failing to pay more than $700,000 in employment taxes he withheld from his employees' pay. The businessman, Frank Stevens, not only failed to pay over the withheld payroll taxes to the IRS, but he also failed to file the required quarterly employment tax returns for his businesses. Then, after the IRS imposed a trust fund penalty, Stevens kept his bank balances near zero to avoid paying the penalty. In total, Stevens caused a tax loss of approximately $737,128.
Tax preparers.
A Minneapolis tax preparer was sentenced to 12 months and one day in prison for continuing to e-filing returns after he was suspended from the IRS' e-file program for failing to file his own returns. For almost a decade, Sue Yang operated surreptitiously as an e-filing tax preparer by enlisting others to obtain unique electronic filing identification numbers (EFINs) that Yang used to file thousands of tax returns for customers. Yang received approximately $765,000 from his tax preparation business, which he didn't report. Yang caused a tax loss of about $214,297.
Another tax preparer, this one from Houston, was sentenced to 12 years for helping to prepare false tax returns. At the sentencing hearing, the court heard additional evidence describing Cheryl Christin Kissentaner's history of failing to pay her own taxes and civil penalties imposed on her for failing to use due diligence in preparing tax returns. Kissentaner's conduct caused a tax loss of approximately $1.9 million.
Embezzlers.
A former bank vice president pleaded guilty to one count of embezzlement by a bank employee and one count of filing a false federal tax return. Angela Flippin was the vice president and chief operating officer and board secretary at the People's Bank of Moniteau County. Flippin embezzled at least $550,000 from the bank over a six-year period by claiming improper comp time disbursements and more than $8,000 in improper expense reimbursements. Flippin also admitted that she failed to report the amounts that she embezzled from the bank on her 2014, 2015, and 2016 federal income tax returns, which resulted in a total tax loss to the federal government of $96,434.
A California woman was sentenced to 66 months in prison for embezzling more than $1 million from her employer and filing false tax returns. According to court documents, Mai Houa Xiong was employed as a financial manager for a Minneapolis-based property management company that provided financial services to homeowners' associations (HOAs). Between February 2015 and February 2022, Xiong devised and executed a fraud scheme to embezzle funds directly from the accounts to which she had access. As part of the scheme, Xiong repeatedly accessed the HOAs' bank accounts and conducted electronic transfers of funds directly into her personal bank accounts. Xiong then disguised these transfers by mis-labeling them to make it appear as if they were legitimate HOA expenses.
Tax scheme promoters.
An Ohio financial planner pleaded guilty to conspiracy to defraud the United States and helping to file a false tax return. Rao Garuda, the President and Chief Executive Officer of Associated Concepts Agency, Inc. ("ACA"), engaged in a scheme known as the Advanced Legacy Plan or the Ultimate Tax Plan (see below). Garuda marketed the scheme despite being warned by several attorneys that the scheme was illegal; one attorney described the scheme as "clearly fraudulent." Garuda scheme caused or intended to cause a tax loss of more than $2.7 million.
Note. The Ultimate Tax Plan scheme was marketed as a way for clients to claim charitable contribution deductions without giving up control over the assets they allegedly donated to charity. The scheme promoters advised clients they could still access their donated assets for their own personal use through tax-free loans and could "buy back" their donated property at a significantly discounted rate.
Florida attorney, Michael L. Meyer, was indicted for conspiracy to defraud the United States, mail and wire fraud conspiracy, helping to prepare false tax returns, conspiracy to obstruct an official proceeding, and other crimes arising out of his promotion of an illegal tax shelter scheme, the "Ultimate Tax Plan," which involved creating false charitable contribution tax deductions. According to the government, Meyer and his co-conspirators allegedly have earned more than $10 million from selling the Ultimate Tax Plan.
Tax evaders and false return filers.
The owner of a concrete company agreed to plead guilty one count of tax evasion related to a multi-year scheme to underreport income on his tax returns. According to the government, Cleber Gomes Pecanha cashed customer checks and did not deposit the receipts in his business bank accounts. Pecanha also failed to tell his tax preparer that he was cashing checks from customers and only gave the tax preparer his bank statements as support for his tax filings. Hiding his income in this manner resulted in a tax loss of more than $1.8 million.
The owner of an artificial turf company pleaded guilty to failing to report nearly $9 million in business income and attempting to evade more than $946,000 in federal income taxes. According to the government, Craig Steven Voyton's business made more than $1.5 million per year. Voyton attempted to conceal this income from the IRS by providing his customers with false Forms W-9, Request for Taxpayer Identification Number and Certification. While Voyton was hiding his business income from the IRS, he purchased over $60,000 in cryptocurrency and real estate using company funds. Voyton's failure to report all his business's income produced a tax loss of approximately $946,479.
A New York woman pleaded guilty to helping to prepare a false tax return. According to the government, Alice Bixuan Zhang of Queens, New York, co-owned and operated two acupuncture businesses with locations throughout New York City. Zhang created fake business deductions by cashing checks, drawn on the business accounts and made payable to fake management companies, at a check-cashing business and then using the money for personal expenses. Zhang did not disclose the cash to her tax preparer. This scheme resulted in a tax loss of over $784,000.
A Michigan insurance salesman was sentenced to 36 months in prison for filing false tax returns, making false statements to a bankruptcy court, and making false statements to the Justice Department's Tax Division. According to the government, Donald Stanley LaVigne did not report insurance commissions and other income he earned on tax returns he filed with the IRS over a six-year period. In letters he sent to the IRS, LaVigne falsely claimed that the commissions were not income to him. When LaVigne filed for bankruptcy, he did not disclose the IRS as a creditor on the schedules attached to his bankruptcy petition even though he knew he owed the IRS taxes for several years.
A New Jersey businessman was sentenced to one year and one day in prison for filing a false corporate income tax return with the IRS. According to the government, Gabriel Ferrari of Edison, who owned an automotive repair business, used business funds to pay for personal items, including gambling on horse races. Ferrari concealed this diversion of business income by not disclosing it to his return preparer, thus causing the preparation and filing of a false corporate tax return. In addition, Ferrari failed to pay employment taxes in the amount of $291,600 based on an unreported cash payroll.